Empathy Over Algorithms: Why Smarter AI Still Needs Employee Trust to Succeed

The next generation of artificial intelligence is within reach, but it will never reach its full potential without employee buy-in and empathetic management.

Artificial intelligence (AI) capabilities are advancing faster than ever, promising to eliminate even the most complicated operational workflows. But this can only be achieved with the trust and oversight of your employees, who are uniquely capable of making or breaking this transformation. Often, it’s their willingness to participate and collaborate that leads to the successful adoption of AI initiatives. 

So how do you gain their buy-in? 

Your organization should focus on three key actions: show genuine empathy for employee concerns, present AI as a tool that enhances rather than replaces human work, and promote a culture that prioritizes people-first, human-centric work. 

Let’s explore each of these three actions to help your organization successfully implement AI initiatives that employees trust and are eager to embrace.

Empathize with Your Employees’ Situation

Have you ever been left out of a decision that directly affected you? You probably felt inconvenienced, undervalued, or frustrated. In the workplace, the effects of these exclusionary decisions can run even deeper: Our jobs help shape our sense of identity, so being left out can impact how we see ourselves as much as our financial future. 

That impact is so deeply felt that even the most helpful AI, backed by clear guarantees of safety and responsible use, will struggle to gain traction if employees feel uninformed or excluded. 

Business leaders must be empathetic to their employees in general, but especially when new initiatives have the potential to make them feel threatened and uncertain. By genuinely listening to employees’ concerns and understanding their perspectives, organizations can build a foundation of trust, paving the way for smoother AI adoption and creating goodwill that extends to future initiatives.

For your AI adoption strategy to be successful, your organization must adopt measures that foster trust. According to Forrester, “29% of AI decision-makers said trust is the biggest barrier to generative AI adoption in their organization. Organizations that prioritize transparency, accuracy, and ethics will be best positioned to leverage genAI responsibly.”

Judy Bloch, VP, Executive Advisor for Financial Services at Medallia, who has held customer experience leadership roles at Sprint, Citi, and UMB, saw this happen with one of her financial services clients. The organization was attempting to roll out a conversational AI bot. The tech wasn’t flawed, but the initiative failed because employees didn’t trust it. The second rollout of the bot turned this missed opportunity into a success by taking a different approach: this time, employees were included, empowered, and given the time they needed to understand the technology. This shift fostered a sense of ownership and psychological safety, turning skeptics into champions. 

AI success isn’t just about algorithms — it’s about people.

Position AI as an Enhancement, Not a Replacement

“AI’s greatest value isn’t what it can do, but what it can free us up to do,” says Melissa Arronte, PhD and VP, Executive Advisor for Employee Experience at Medallia, who previously served as a leader in HR and analytics at Liberty Mutual Insurance and Citizens Bank. She believes AI can eliminate routine, low value-add tasks from workflows, empowering employees to focus on providing empathetic, personalized service to customers. 

The techniques and capabilities of AI are advancing so quickly that AI will be able to tackle complex customer problems and concerns, enabling these conversations to become rather routine. That frees up humans to do higher-value tasks, particularly those that require empathy and human-to-human interaction. “The biggest promise of AI right now is to take off work that’s really time-consuming and repetitive, and allow us to do work we didn’t have time for before,” Arronte explains. “This gives us the ability to use our brain in a way that AI can’t.”

Many such tasks require flexible problem-solving that considers the full context of individual experiences with a business to deliver the best possible resolution to their problems. AI lacks this flexibility because it can only mimic humanity without true warmth and empathy. People can feel that difference, and those feelings impact customer loyalty and satisfaction with brands. While AI may certainly be able to aid in these higher-value tasks, it cannot fully replace the human intuition and planning capabilities that enable people to more holistically understand and act on problems. 

In short, businesses should enable AI to handle the mundane, so humans can do what is most meaningful. Whether it’s solving problems that require flexible thinking, connecting with customers on a personal level, or imagining new solutions — these are still uniquely human capabilities. AI is therefore not a threat to human creativity, flexibility, or empathy. Instead, AI is a tool that can amplify these qualities by reducing tedium and stress, which increases employee motivation and ability to deliver better service. 

Promote a People-First, Human-Centric Work Culture

Lastly, and most importantly, the previous two actions are only possible with a human-centric, people-first work culture that empowers employees to go above and beyond for customers, even if that means taking a bit longer to arrive at a holistic resolution to a customer problem, according to Arronte. Customers can immediately sense if a company culture prioritizes their employees. When employees feel confident enough on customer service calls to make recommendations, guide customers to the right solutions, and even gently point out mistakes, it sends a strong message: their organization has empowered them with the time, training, and tools they need to deliver truly helpful service. 

For example, I recently bought a camera with a couple of lenses, only to find out a newer version of the camera was being released just days later. Canceling my order required a call into customer service. Not only did they let me know the lenses I’d bought wouldn’t work with the newer model, but they also helped me cancel the original order and place a new one. The agent expressed genuine excitement for me. They even followed up with a personal email to confirm everything was squared away. Never did I feel rushed or inconvenienced. In fact, I actually felt good about spending more with them, instead of going with one of the other brands I’d been considering. That experience made me a customer for life. 

The AI in this example was hiding in plain sight. The instant my call was received, all of my details were readily available for the customer service agent. We could get right to talking about what I needed, and the agent had all the context needed to help me out. AI expands employees’ capabilities and gives them more time to focus on solving the root of customer issues – instead of getting bogged down by repetitive tasks like re-identifying the customer. However, what ultimately made the difference was that the agent was empowered to spend more time actually connecting with me – all while solving my problem in under 10 minutes. It spoke volumes about the kind of culture the organization fostered, and the support they’re willing to give their employees so that they can deliver empathetic service. 

Make Your Employees Champions of AI

AI may be evolving at lightning speed, but its true potential lies in how well people are empowered to use it. Organizations that prioritize trust, empathy, and a human-centric culture are the ones best positioned to unlock AI’s full value – not by replacing people, but by supporting them. 

When employees feel heard, supported, and equipped with the right tools, they become more than just users of technology — they become champions of it. And when that happens, AI becomes more than a productivity tool; it becomes a catalyst for better service, stronger loyalty, and more meaningful work.

Whether you’re AI-curious or already all-in, check out our hub of AI in CX resources to help you learn, apply, and level up your AI game for faster insights, smarter actions, and bigger impact.